Stereotyping in the Classroom

by Amy Sullivan on January 11, 2012

Image Credit: Creative Commons, Flickr.

Sometimes, stereotypes find their way into the classroom. We pretend this doesn’t happen, but it does. Often, we hold preconceived ideas about our students, the homes they come from, and the activities that fill out-of-school time.

I know this statement to be true because before I taught on the Navajo Reservation, I thought I knew a great deal about the Navajo people.

Ten minutes before I stepped on Reservation soil,  I stopped at a gas station close to my new school.

Whispering voices and tiny footsteps shuffled and followed me out of the building and towards my car. I looked over my shoulder and saw four, young boys.

One set of dirty sneakers kicked rocks. The others stood in a cluster. All stared at the ground.

“We heard you were coming.”

A young, white female with an Illinois, license plate, and a car packed to the roof with belongings. I wasn’t hard to spot.

More rock kicking.

I nodded. I bet they heard. I heard about them too. I heard many refused their culture and dismissed their history. I heard their parents drank anything containing alcohol, even hairspray. I heard little joy resounded in such an empty place. I heard education held minimal value here.

“My mom bought me a shirt to wear on the first day. It says Reebok. You can see it at school.”

The rock kicking stopped as four sets of dark, brown eyes glanced up.

Could a fifteen-second conversation about a new, Reebok shirt challenge everything I heard? Maybe. Maybe now I would do more than hear. Maybe now I’d rely less on stereotypes and just start to learn.

 Can you think of a time when a relationship with one of your students pushed you to see beyond the stereotypes?

-Amy teaches Special Education and blogs at Amy L. Sullivan

  • http://onlyhere-onlynow.blogspot.com HopeUnbroken

    well, my students are my own kids. but one has dyslexia and processing disorders. and i find myself fighting stereotypes every. single. day. sometimes i think his progress is hindered more by my expectations and what i perceive he can/cannot do, rather than his own limitations. fresh eyes. that’s what i pray for each and every morning before we head to the table together.
    thanks for the reminder, amy.
    steph

  • http://amylsullivan.blogspot.com/ Amy Sullivan

    Steph,
    Good insight. Sometimes I think it’s tough to make big realizations like this about our own kids. Good for you for noticing this is something you do and catching yourself. I didn’t know your son has dyslexia and processing problems.

  • http://expateducator.com Janet | expateducator.com

    I work in an international school. My students are of American, Chinese, Indian, Iranian, Israeli, Portugese, Japanese, and Korean descent.

    My first year teaching, students asked if they could have a popcorn treat while watching an academic movie. Then, one of my students piped in with the question, “What about Cyril (the name has been changed)?”

    It was the season of Ramadan. Cyril was the only Muslim in class – and he was fasting (or partial fasting – whatever a 10-year-old can do). After much discussion, the class decided that they could do without popcorn to support Cyril and his religious practice.

    I love many things about teaching overseas – but one of the things I love most is the mix of faces, religions, and cultures. Stereotypes form when we see a group of people as “the other.” When we attach personal faces to people of many descents, stereotypes disappear.

    This week’s impromptu discussion began when one student declared that “Mission Impossible” portrayed a stereotypical account of life in Dubai.

    Janet | expateducator.com

    • http://expateducator.com Janet | expateducator.com

      Can you edit my comment so that “descent” is spelled correctly in the first paragraph. Silly me.

    • http://amylsullivan.blogspot.com/ Amy Sullivan

      Janet,
      So glad you made your way here. I bet you have amazing stories to tell, and I hope this is the first of many! The one you shared about Cyril moves me. I love the way kids see and think and question before we do. It’s inspiring.

      I agree with what you are saying about attaching real names and faces as a way to battle stereotypes. In fact, that’s exactly when some of the stereotypes I believed to be true started to melt. As soon as I stopped reading about the Navajo and listening to stories, and just started having real interactions, my perceptions changed.

      Thanks, Janet. Hope you visit again. I’m off to check out your web space.

    • http://www.lauraleighparker.com Laura Parker

      Janet– I, too, am so glad you shared this! I currently live in Thailand. I am not teaching in a school system, but I totally see the advantage of the constant mixing of cultures/religions/peoples– It’s a lot harder to stereotype when “they” become real people.

      I hope you’ll share some more of your experiences here! I loved this story!

  • http://immersionblogapy.blogspot.com lori

    Aim, this is excellent. Love it. You must write more about this experience. Just shared to fb :)

    • http://www.lauraleighparker.com Laura Parker

      I agree– I would love to hear more about what it was like teaching there . . . such a powerful experience, I have no doubt. Thanks, Amy for sharing a taste of it with us!

  • http://amylsullivan.blogspot.com/ Amy Sullivan

    Lori,
    Thanks for sharing on FB. You know my time there was so special and life changing. I could write loads on it, and I should because you know what? I’m forgetting some of the stories from when I lived there. That’s sad.

  • Pingback: Expect the Unexpected in Your Students

Previous post:

Next post: